The Quiet Car

If you’ve ever spent time riding Amtrak or New Jersey transit, you’ll know there is a car dedicated to peace and quiet, aptly named the Quiet Car.

I have spent an enormous amount of time on these trains over the years, back and forth from Trenton or Philly to Manhattan.

For those of you who know me, you know you would never find me willingly in the Quiet Car.  The word ‘quiet’ is not how anyone would ever describe me. My gift of gab goes way back.  Per an earlier blog, you may remember that I was sent to stand in the hallway by Sister Florine when I was in 1st grade, for talking.  Getting in trouble for talking was my specialty right through to high school graduation.  Actually, still to this day, lol.

So yeah, the Quiet Car is not for me.  Especially, as most times that I am on the train, I am usually with someone else.  Being with someone else, naturally, there will be talking.

However, there are times when the train is so crowded that you have no choice but to sit in the Quiet Car.

If you’ve never ridden in the Quiet Car, let me tell you, there is a whole other culture in there.  The people who ride in that car, take it very seriously.  There’s always at least one Quiet Car Enforcer.  I imagine the group convenes at some point to elect one of their kind to this high office. 

The QCE shoulders the responsibility with all the gravitas of a Supreme Court Judge.  Well, maybe that’s not such a great analogy because the current Supreme Court is very short on gravitas these days.  Long on subverting the Constitution, but short on gravitas.

Anyway, god forbid the QCE feels you have violated the rules.

The rules are fairly straightforward.

Per Amtrak: Limit conversation and speak in subdued tones. No phone calls. Use headphones for electronic devices. 

The system relies on mutual passenger respect and self-policing policy.

But who determines if you have violated the rules? You may think you are abiding them. But some in that car, the QCE’s, have a different interpretation of the rules. Violate their version and you will feel their wrath.

Speaking to your coworker or friend in a hushed, quiet tone? First, you’ll get a glare, the stink eye.  If your quiet talking continues for a period they deem too long, they escalate to throat clearing.  If you still aren’t getting the message, then the shushing begins.  If you reach def con level 1, where you have caused them to, god forbid, speak, they will sternly scold you with a “This is the Quiet Car” statement.

Well, excuuuuse me. (Please read that in your best Steve Martin voice).

Last time I checked, this was called the Quiet Car. Not the Silent Car.

No one is throwing a party, yapping loudly into their phones, or disrupting the peace in any way.  You know, everything you’d find in the regular cars.

Those of us in the Quiet Car who don’t want to be in the Quiet Car, have indeed taken it down a notch, nay, many, many notches.  In fact, our tones are so hushed they’d barely register on a decibel level reader.

I was wondering what the take on all this is, since it is rather nebulous, open to so much interpretation, as it is. I googled it and found a Reddit thread on the subject.

Most users on Reddit agree that any audible sound or conversation that disturbs others around you violates both the unwritten and the official standard of the car.

Well, then.  If that’s the case, it really is the Silent Car and not the Quiet Car.

We gabbers are outnumbered it seems.  The unwritten code put forth by the QCE’s seems ironclad.  If you find yourself then in the mis-named Quiet Car, best to know the rules, both the official and the unwritten. 

Or be prepared to be shushed otherwise.

Next
Next

Calendars